When Schools Punish Individuality: A Glimpse into Aiden’s Day
Today, Aiden had a rough day at school. It wasn’t because he wasn’t trying or being disruptive—far from it. His only “offense” was not following along like a good little robot during a reading exercise. While his classmates were reading aloud, Aiden was listening attentively but not looking at the book. This alone was enough to trigger his teacher’s frustration, as she assumed he wasn’t paying attention.
When she called him out and told him to follow along, he calmly responded that he was paying attention but simply wasn’t reading along in the book. Not content with his answer, she tried to challenge him, asking where they were in the text to prove her point. Aiden responded confidently with the correct page number—28—but she snapped back, trying to insist he was wrong. The rest of the class confirmed that Aiden was correct. She then corrected him with a spiteful “Nope. The first sentence on page 29,” as though being right to the exact sentence was the only thing that mattered.
Aiden knew what the class was discussing, but he got the page wrong by one. That’s not the issue here, though. The issue is that he was singled out, not because he didn’t know what was happening, but because he wasn’t conforming to the teacher’s rigid expectations. This is a teacher who, from the beginning, seemed to struggle with Aiden’s unique approach to learning and his refusal to fit neatly into her mold of how a student “should” behave.
I made the school well aware of Aiden’s needs before he entered this class. I explained that he might not always do things the conventional way but that he was still learning and participating. I also warned them that if he felt humiliated, overwhelmed, or talked down to, his reaction might be strong. Despite this, his teacher chose to ignore my advice, and today she did all three—humiliated him, overwhelmed him, and spoke to him in a tone that was sharp and biting.
When I spoke to her on the phone about the incident, she spoke to me in the same condescending tone that Aiden had described. Her voice was raised, and she spoke through gritted teeth, clearly irritated and defensive. I know Aiden was telling me the truth because I heard it firsthand.
The Bigger Picture
This isn’t just about one bad day or one difficult interaction. This is about a system that doesn’t value different ways of learning and punishes children who don’t conform. It’s about educators who, instead of adapting their methods to meet their students’ needs, try to force those students into a one-size-fits-all box. When they can’t, or won’t, they blame the child and call it defiance.
What Aiden experienced today was a reminder of how far we still have to go to make schools a place where all children—not just the ones who fit the mold—are respected and valued. No child should be made to feel small or inadequate because they learn differently or don’t follow along in the expected way. And no parent should have to explain why their child deserves understanding and respect.
As parents, we need to keep advocating, keep speaking up, and keep pushing for change. Our kids deserve better than this.
I withdrew him. Miacademy, here we come! 😉
Comments
Post a Comment